I’d like to share my initiative system and get some feedback, I hope this will improve your Games as much as mine.
Its simple, instead of rolling initiative for every NPC on the table, roll once for everyone, or a few distinct groups. Each player rolls for initiative like usual. Whoever matches or exceeds the NPC’s initiative gets to do their round before them, then you just switch between NPC’s and Players after everyone of that Group is done with their turn.
Pros:
- No longer do you need to track initiative!
- players, as well as enemys, can work together during their round Cons:
- it screws up some Suprise mechanics
Some of the most creative fun things my Players came up that way were to ride the back of a purple worm into a guard tower, thrwing another player up who could use the vantage point to snipe some enemies.
It also nice for more mundane reasons like getting out of the way of an aoe effect from fellow party member. Generally it feels very fluid and casual. Try it out and i’d love to hear what happened ^^
I think if it works for your table, then go for it. I personally enjoy the initiative rules from ShadowDark, where whoever rolls highest goes first, then turns proceed around the table in clockwise order. The whole game is played this way, actually
Do you find players taking advantage of this by choosing their seats to guarantee that they can perform combos most of the time?
In ShadowDark, you get movement and 1 action per turn. Actions can be interacting with the environment or other characters out of combat; or attacking, casting a spell, or using action to double movement while in combat. The intent is to keep gameplay flowing and not bog down on any one player. I haven’t personally had anyone try to take advantage of that system, and I’m not exactly sure how they would go about it.
You said that turns proceed around the table in clockwise order. That means two players wanting to combo with each other could sit next to each other, guaranteeing that they would have their turns one after another in most cases, with no chance for anyone else (like an enemy) to do anything in between. (The exception being when the second player rolls highest initiative at the table.)
I was asking if you’ve seen players take advantage of that.
Ah I get what you’re asking. No, the players are usually much more focused on survival than trying to game the system. ShadowDark is dangerous and unforgiving.
Would it really be a problem if they did?
In any case the nice thing about DnD is that it’s functionally designed to be rules-flexible. (Most TTRPGs are.)
Even if something is absolutely game breaking, that’s okay as long as everyone is having fun. (This includes the DM,)
Not necessarily. I was just curious.
It does feel a bit odd, to settle above the table, but I don’t see a problem with exploiting things.
I have used the “enemy group initiative” for a while in my games. I rarely have enough friendly NPC’s with the group to make separate rolls an issue.
Works pretty well in my groups.
Rolling one initiative for each type of enemy is what is recommended in the DMG. How is this different? You sometimes group together different types as well?
I think they are saying that the players get a unified turn and the enemies get a unified turn.
That’s how I read this, too.
What stealth mechanics were getting mucked?
I’ve never had a problem with stealth…and this is pretty similar to how I deal with large waves of trash mobs. (Everybody loves a fireball… right?)
In any case the way I handle stealth and perception checks about the same as with initiative- if they’re staying in a pack, at least- then that pack rolls once for the check (maybe with advantage, if the pack is more competent.)
The way I see it, in a group, you usually only have one or two scouts watching an approach, with everyone else not paying attention. Like goblins passing by where people are hidden- the ones in the back are assuming the ones in the front paid attention.
Of course I might ask for another check if they try something ridiculous. (Like sneaking into the boss chamber or something.)
But for surprise mechanics that’s usually enough (along with sneak attack, and going back into stealth, etc)
I know some dms just role once for the enemy group and they go all at that point and it gets like you say with all players and monsters alternating.




